They Gave Their Yesterday
Entanglement by Robert M Kidd is an absolutely mesmerising epic historical novel that I just could not put down. If you only read one book on World War I, make sure it is this one. Entanglement shows the war from a human point of view. You cannot detach feelings from action.
Robert M Kidd has created a rich tapestry of events showing how the ripples of the past connect with the present, as we follow Claire in 2005 and Clara, her great grandmother, through the tumultuous early twentieth century – from the suffragette movement to the battlefields of France and beyond. The tale is told in a narrative from diaries and letters. The voices alternate but Clara’s is the principal voice.
At the start of the twentieth century, women were gagged. “Women didn’t count. They had neither a voice nor the vote.” Clara, born to a German Jewish banking family, living in Britain, stepped out of the confines of her class to make her voice count. “The… poisonous bigotry… brings me to despair of my class.” Playing a major role in the suffragettes, Clara was not afraid of protest, prison or hunger strikes. The streets of London held no fear for her, as she saw all the people in their abject poverty. “Poverty and drink go hand in hand.” She wanted to step up and make a difference.
Clara was a pacifist. It was ironic that the love of her life was an officer in the Coldstream Guards. The pair complemented each other. Their love and mutual respect are clear to all.
Claire had a strong bond with her grandfather. It is only after his death and the discovery of the Gatehouse (unknown to her but left in his will to her) that she begins to unpack who her grandfather is; where he came from; and why he behaved as he did. This knowledge is unpacked in the form of diaries and letters.
Robert M Kidd has produced a marvellous account of the events leading to World War I and of the war itself. He brings history alive for the reader far better than any text book ever could. We witness the effects of the war on ordinary people. He shows us the cost to humanity, and the ripples through time. How innocent babies carry the heavy weight of adult’s decisions down the generations.
Continue reading


